It’s been a while since we’ve been able to get our hands on some quality raw milk with the cream on. It was so fun to get back into the swing of making butter and I wanted to show all of you just how easy it is to do.
I bought 1/2 gallon wide-mouthed canning jars to get our milk in. They are easy to handle and make creaming them easy as well.

I only take off the cream as I open a new jar, and I always leave a little on to mix in with the milk. (Just shake the jar good before pouring any out). The milk “keeps” better if the cream is on it.
To scoop the cream out, I use a serving spoon with a bent handle and scoop it directly into a pint canning jar.
The cream jar stays in the refrigerator until it is full, which for this particular cow, is after about 2 gallons.

I didn't have a lid handy, thus the reason for the plastic over top.
On Butter-Making Day, I pull the cream out and let it get to room temperature.
I pour the cream into my Bosch mixer with the whisk attachment on it. {some people use a blender and that works just as well, but I hate cleaning blenders!}

I run the mixer on medium for several minutes. You’ll hear two “sound” changes in your mixing.
The first time you hear the mixer sound different, it is when your cream turns to whipped cream. If you want, you can stop here, add a bit of vanilla and sugar to taste and have homemade whipped cream for your strawberry shortcake! However, this is a butter tutorial, so carry on…
The second sound change will be butter. You’ll also be able to tell you’ve hit butter because the buttermilk will splash all over the mixer/blender.

Butter!
I get the butter off the whisks and scrap down the bowl and pour off the buttermilk into another pint jar.

I REALLY need to find some jar lids!
This buttermilk can be used in recipes during the upcoming week.
Next, I transfer the butter from the mixer to a glass bowl. Glass is just a preference of mine. I also really like using a wooden spoon in this next step, but the last of my wooden spoons split in two the other day, so I had to use a new plastic paddle-type spoon I picked up the other day at the bulk food store.
Now, here’s the important step…
Take your butter bowl and pour cold water over it {not warm because your butter will be hard to handle if it’s all melted
} Smoosh your butter around in the water (it will look murky), use your spoon to hold the butter in place, and pour off the water. Repeat AT LEAST 4 times–water should be relatively clear by the time you are finished.

Why do you do this step? Because if you don’t, you will have cow-y tasting butter. I like cows and all, but not in my butter.
Finally, I transfer the butter to whatever I am using as a butter dish, cover and refrigerate. You can leave it out for a time, but I tend to just keep it in the refrigerator to be on the safe side.

The finished product!
Oh, and if you like salted butter, just add in a bit to taste (I honestly don’t know how much because I don’t make salted butter).
And there you have your own incredibly easy, incredibly tasty homemade butter! Yay for you!